profile

Social Profit Stack

Discover the GOLD. It's hiding in plain sight 🫣


Hey Reader,

It’s mid-November. You've opened a blank page to write your year-end email, and the first sentence you type reads, ā€œThis has been a year of incredible growth.ā€

You delete it. Type it again. You giggle and wonder whether anyone has ever donated because of that sentence. You keep jamming out a few more sentences meant to inspire your donors. Another call comes in. Distracted, once again.

Sound familiar?

I worked with an executive director recently who found herself trapped in the same loop.

Maybe you recognize it: four staff members. One person handling the writing between program meetings. Every December, the appeal looks the same: a list of programs, a thank-you, and a donate button.

Last year’s version raised $4,100 from their email list, and she knew it could do better. She simply didn’t know what was missing.

So, she tried AI. She typed, ā€œPlease write a year-end appeal for our literacy nonprofit.ā€ The result was polished, warm, and completely forgettable. It could have belonged to any charity in the country. She told me, ā€œIt sounds like us, but it doesn’t feel like us.ā€

She was ready to give up using AI altogether.

I encouraged her to flip the prompt. Instead of asking AI to write for her, she asked it to interview her, one question at a time, about the past twelve months. After a few minutes of back-and-forth, she mentioned a Grade 4 student who read his first chapter book aloud to his little sister on the bus ride home.

She’d never shared that story because it felt too small. That moment became the whole appeal. The December email raised $9,800, and more donors replied to it than to anything they’d sent all year.

Here’s the takeaway: AI’s best job at year-end isn’t writing. It’s discovery. More like a metal detector than a jeweller. It leads you to find the gold buried over the past year. šŸŖŽ

Of course, you do the polishing. When you ask AI to write first, it fills the gaps with averages because that’s all it has. When you ask it to dig first, it pulls only what your organization knows.

In practice, that looks like these three prompts, in this order:

1. The interview prompt: ask AI to question you about your year until a specific moment surfaces, with a person, a place, and something someone said.

2. The pattern prompt: paste in a few program notes or volunteer updates, with names and donor details removed, and ask what outcomes keep showing up. That becomes the ā€œbecause of youā€ line in your email.

3. The donor’s-eye prompt: once you have a draft, ask AI to read it as a first-time donor and tell you exactly where it loses interest. Only then should you write, or ask AI, using the real stories.

Timing matters. According to M+R’s 2026 Benchmarks study, December accounted for 37% of nonprofits’ annual online revenue in 2025. That’s a lot of giving riding on a handful of emails. You don’t need more emails this month. You need your best story in the emails you already send.

Block 20 minutes this week and paste this prompt into ChatGPT, Claude, or whichever AI tool you use:

Nonprofit Storytelling Prompt

ā€œYou’re an experienced nonprofit storyteller. Interview me about the last 12 months at [organization name]. Ask one question at a time and wait for my answer. Dig for specific moments, like a person, a place, or something someone said, not program statistics. After eight questions, list the three moments with the most emotional pull and tell me why each one would matter to a donor.ā€

Answer honestly and don’t edit yourself. The moment that feels too small to mention is usually the one. If you’re not sure where to begin, or you’ve found your story but aren’t sure how to shape it into an appeal, hit reply and we can run through it together. Let’s discover your organization’s gold. Your donors are waiting to hear it, promise.

Link šŸ”—

The best AI prompts are specific and give AI a clear task, audience, tone, context, constraints, and desired format, rather than relying on vague instructions. Let our friends at GiveButter introduce you to the ā€œgoldā€ in fundraising prompts right here.

Don’t forget to protect your nonprofit from cybercriminals. This week’s breakdown of Microsoft and the air traffic control system failure highlights how vulnerable we all are. Here’s a practical starting point for reducing exposure and protecting donor trust.

Prompt of the Week ✨

Christmas is coming and I’ll bet there’s someone in your office planning a gift exchange. Let AI play detective. Paste this holiday cheer prompt into your favourite AI tool:

Secret Santa Gift Detective Prompt

Please act as a cheerful gift detective. I’m planning to buy a Secret Santa gift for a coworker. Ask me five quick questions about them, one at a time, like what’s on their desk, what they talk about at lunch, and how they take their coffee. Then suggest three gift ideas under [$ budget], each with a one-line reason it fits them.

Did you love this email? Share your review with a note or a video right here.

Thanks for reading this far. See you in two weeksāœŒšŸ¼

​

Social Profit Stack

Want a simpler digital fundraising strategy? Every other Sunday, I share practical tools, AI ideas, and proven tactics to help you raise more revenue and improve the online donor experience. Free gift inside!

Share this page