Hi Reader,

Let me guess…

You’ve sent the emails, posted on social media, and you’ve even tried a few new online platforms.

But donation page visits? Crickets.

Engagement numbers? Flatlined.

Meanwhile, you’re watching other organizations effortlessly connect with their supporters, and you’re often left wondering, “What am I doing wrong?”

Here’s the truth: You’re not doing it wrong. You’re probably doing the same things everyone else is doing.

And in 2026, “same” equals hidden.

The donors who care about your mission are out there. Like you, they’re also drowning in noise. Another email blast won’t cut through. Neither will another Instagram post that gets lost in the algorithm.

What if the answer isn’t doing more of what you’re already doing, but doing something completely different?

Today, I’ll share strategies that actually break through the noise. Not because they’re louder, but because they’re going in a different direction. More human.

Why 2026 Will Demand a New Approach

Here’s what’s changed: Your donors aren’t only ignoring generic content anymore; they’ve trained themselves not to see it.

Skipping ads, scrolling past emails. There’s a tinge of can’t be bothered.

The economic pressures haven’t let up. Competition for donor dollars is fierce. And your supporters have developed incredibly sophisticated filters for tuning out anything that feels like “just another ask.”

The organizations winning right now? They’ve stopped interrupting their donors and started inviting them into something worth their time.

5 Engagement Strategies That Actually Work in 2026

1/ Launch a Voice Note Campaign

Record a 30-60 second voice message for your mid-level donors. Thank them for their support. Share a quick impact story. Ask how they’re doing.Tools like Loom (audio-only mode) or even WhatsApp make this simple. The response rates will shock you, because guess what? Nobody else is doing this.

2/ Create a Private Community (Not Public Social Media)

Your donors don’t want to engage with you on Instagram where their boss, their ex, and 500 acquaintances are watching.

Start a private Skool community, Discord server, or a simple Facebook Group where supporters can connect with your team. Share behind-the-scenes updates. Host monthly virtual coffee chats. Let donors ask questions directly.

This strategy isn’t only for content, it’s relationship building. Don’t forget to invite your supporters.

3/ Open up “Office Hours”

Block off one hour each month and invite donors to book 15-minute calls with you. No agenda. No ask. Just conversation.

You’ll learn more about what motivates your supporters in these calls than from a hundred surveys. And donors will feel genuinely seen, not like a line item in your CRM.

Starting new opportunities like this may take a while to get going, but if you share the link in your emails and social posts, you’ll begin to build a way to connect with your organization.

4/ Master the “Curiosity Gap” in Your Subject Lines

Forget “Newsletter - January 2026.” Your subject line needs to create an irresistible gap between what donors know and what they want to know.

Try these:

• “We almost didn’t tell you this…”
• “The question nobody’s asking about [your cause].”
• “What happened after you stopped reading our emails?”
• “Sarah’s response when we asked her about hope.”

That curiosity can lead to more clicks. Then deliver value.

5/ Send Personalized Video Messages

Pick your top 20-30 donors and record individual 30-second videos for them using Loom or Vidyard. Use their name. Cite something specific about their giving history. Share the impact of what their gift made possible.

Yes, it takes time. But one of these videos creates more connections than 50 mass emails.

6/ Let AI Handle the Grunt Work (So You Can Focus on Connecting)

Here’s the secret successful fundraisers are using in 2026: AI tools that free up time for the human work that actually matters. Use AI to:

Draft personalized thank-you notes based on donor history (then add your personal touch) Analyze giving patterns to identify who’s ready for a deeper conversation Generate multiple subject line variations and test what resonates Transcribe and summarize donor calls so you can focus on listening, not note-taking Create first drafts of impact stories from your program data

Tools like ChatGPT, Claude, or nonprofit-specific platforms with AI features can handle repetitive tasks. You bring the heart, strategy, and authentic relationship-building.

The goal isn’t to automate the connection. It helps automate everything else, so you have more time to connect with your donors.

The Bottom Line

Stop trying to out-content the content flood.

Start creating moments of genuine human connection that your donors actually want to experience.

In 2026, the organizations that win aren’t the ones with the biggest email lists or the most followers. They’re the ones that make donors feel like people, not prospects.

Which of these innovative strategies will you try first to start building more meaningful donor relationships in 2026?

Reply and let me know! I read every response.

P.S. If you’re still relying on the same engagement playbook you’ve been using since 2023, we need to talk. The donors are still out there. But they’re not where you think they are.

Link 💜

Ever stuck wondering how to design or write the best PowerPoint presentation? Start with Gamma. Take your document, upload it, and watch this software do the hard work. I've shared this one before but it keeps getting better.
​
Ready to create an online community but not interested in using FB Groups? Check out Skool. It cuts through the clutter and helps you grow.

Most fundraisers don’t need more dashboards. They need clarity on what to do next. I’m building LandingLab to run one focused experiment on your donation page and deliver a short report with clear next steps. If you want to use AI in a way that actually improves fundraising, join the early BETA waitlist!